During the 2026–2027 school year, nearly 76,000 children and young people are studying at 306 educational institutions in the de-occupied parts of the Kherson region. More than 5,000 children attend classes in person. Where school kitchens have not yet been restored or renovation work is still underway, schools have to procure catering services, with prepared meals delivered directly to the schools.
We analyzed four catering service procurements for educational institutions on the right bank of the Kherson region. The same company, Service Rest Group LLC, won all four. The fact that one supplier serves several schools is not, in itself, a violation. However, the combination of circumstances raises concerns: none of the four procedures involved effective price competition, all four were re-tenders following unsuccessful initial attempts, and the estimated value increased by 11–32% in three cases. Meanwhile, the main technical and quantitative specifications remained unchanged. These circumstances raise questions that warrant further scrutiny.
Four schools, four procurements
In late August 2026, four educational institutions announced procurements for catering services involving the delivery of prepared meals:
Bila Krynytsia Main Gymnasium of the Velykooleksandrivska Settlement Council
UA-2026-08-20-013258-a, with an estimated value of UAH 511,670 excluding VAT.Orlivka Main Educational Complex “General Education School, Grades I–III — Kindergarten” of the Kochubeivka Village Council, Joint Territorial Community, Kherson Region, Kochubeivka Education District
UA-2026-08-14-005994-a, with an estimated value of UAH 664,800 excluding VAT.Arkhanhelske Main General Secondary Education Institution of the Vysokopillia Settlement Council
UA-2026-08-18-008338-a, with an estimated value of UAH 180,300 excluding VAT.Vysokopillia Main General Secondary Education Institution
UA-2026-08-17-010851-a, with an estimated value of UAH 687,280 excluding VAT.
All four procedures were conducted as open tenders under the special rules applicable during martial law. Funding was to come from local budgets and a state budget subvention.
However, despite formally being open tenders, all four procedures effectively became procurements without price competition: only one company, Service Rest Group LLC, submitted a bid.
An initial review of these four procedures already reveals a recurring pattern that should be examined across the group rather than in isolation.
The most important pattern: repeat procedures
We were struck by the fact that all four contracting authorities re-announced their catering procurements very shortly after their initial procedures failed. The subject of procurement was identical: CPV code 021:2015 55520000-1, “Catering services,” for students in grades 1–4 and grades 5–11.
The initial tenders, announced in early August, failed for various reasons:
No bids were submitted (UA-2026-08-07-010076-a, UA-2026-08-07-006208-a).
A bidder failed to correct discrepancies identified in the submitted information and/or documents after the bids were opened, and/or changed the subject of procurement while correcting discrepancies within 24 hours of the electronic procurement system posting a notice requesting their correction (UA-2026-08-05-007043-a).
The identified violations of public procurement legislation could not be remedied because the estimated value had been incorrectly stated when the procurement was published (UA-2026-08-07-011663-a).
Repeating a procurement after an unsuccessful tender is standard practice. The question is how the estimated value changed afterward. The most notable feature is a substantial increase in the estimated value following the failed tenders in three procurements.
- Orlivka Main Educational Complex of the Kochubeivka Village Council
Initial procurement, UA-2026-08-05-007043-a: UAH 540,150 excluding VAT.
Repeat procurement, UA-2026-08-14-005994-a: UAH 664,800 excluding VAT.
Difference: UAH 124,650, or +23.08%. - Arkhanhelske Main General Secondary Education Institution of the Vysokopillia Settlement Council
Initial procurement, UA-2026-08-07-011663-a: UAH 162,270 excluding VAT.
Repeat procurement, UA-2026-08-18-008338-a: UAH 180,300 excluding VAT.
Difference: UAH 18,030, or +11.11%. - Vysokopillia Main General Secondary Education Institution
Initial procurement, UA-2026-08-07-006208-a: UAH 522,225 excluding VAT.
Repeat procurement, UA-2026-08-17-010851-a: UAH 687,280 excluding VAT.
Difference: UAH 165,055, or +31.61%.
Our review of the tender documentation found no substantiated indicators in any of these three cases that would explain such increases in the estimated value over a short period. The procurement subject and the main technical and quantitative specifications—including the number of school days, students, and the sample menu—were identical in both versions of the tender documents. In practice, only the approval date and the bid submission deadline changed.
This does not mean that prices could not have increased for other reasons. Food, fuel, labor, rent, logistics, and other cost components may have changed. But that raises a question: which specific costs increased enough to account for a price rise of 11–32% in just a few days? The procurement documents published on Prozorro do not include a separate calculation of the estimated value.
In response to a request from the State Audit Service of Ukraine (SASU) for information and documents explaining the budget appropriations, technical and quality specifications, and estimated value, the Orlivka Educational Complex explained its methodology for calculating the estimated value, stating that it was based on the number of child-days and the calculated cost of feeding one student per day.
We found that the Kochubeivka Military Administration had published a justification of the technical and quality specifications, budget allocation, and estimated value for the repeat procurement UA-2026-08-14-005994-a, including a detailed cost breakdown showing the components used to calculate the rate per child-day. However, no such calculation for the initial procurement, UA-2026-08-05-007043-a, is publicly available.
At this stage, the analysis establishes that the price changed, but it does not determine the economic reasons for the increase.
The Bilokrynytsia Gymnasium procurement followed a different pattern: the total value decreased by UAH 6,530 (−1.26%)Initial procurement, UA-2026-08-07-010076-a: UAH 518,200 excluding VAT.
Repeat procurement, UA-2026-08-20-013258-a: UAH 511,670 excluding VAT.
Our review of the tender documentation found that the number of meal-service days in the second procurement decreased from 40 to 38. For analysis, the most informative figure is not the total amount but the cost per child-day.
The initial Bilokrynytsia Gymnasium procurement covered 3,400 child-days. The repeat procurement covered 3,230, a 5% decrease from the previous year. Yet the estimated value decreased by only 1.26%.
As a result: initial procurement: UAH 152.41 per child-day; repeat procurement: UAH 158.41 per child-day; increase: 3.94%.
In other words, the 5% reduction in child-days did not lead to a proportional decrease in the estimated value. Instead, the calculated cost per child-day increased. Meanwhile, the recommended menu and the number of students remained unchanged.
The Prozorro procurement documents also contain no separate calculation of the estimated value, showing which specific cost components determined the price. Therefore, the reason for the increase in the cost per child-day cannot be established from the tender documentation alone.
In response to a request from SASU, the contracting authority explained its methodology by referring to the Approximate Methodology for Determining the Estimated Value of the Procurement Subject (Ministry of Economy Order No. 275 of February 18, 2020), a calculation method based on the approved meal cost per child, and an analysis of comparable Prozorro procurements.
However, the response did not include the actual calculation of the estimated value, specific price quotations, or a list of the procurements used for comparison. The Bilokrynytsia Gymnasium also did not provide a direct link to a document or webpage where the calculation could be checked. As a result, the claim that the price reflects the market average and is economically justified cannot be independently verified based on this response. The Bilokrynytsia Main Gymnasium website does not publish a justification of the procurement’s technical and quality specifications.
Four different contracting authorities, one winner
All four procurements were conducted as open tenders. However, only one company submitted a bid in each case: Service Rest Group LLC. It won all four and signed contracts with municipal institutions totaling UAH 2,042,220.
In three of the four procedures, the signed contract price equaled the estimated procurement value. The exception was procurement UA-2026-08-14-005994-a, where the difference was small—just UAH 1,830.
Thus, none of the four completed procedures involved genuine price competition between multiple bidders.
This is an important risk indicator, but it is not proof of a violation. There are objective reasons why the pool of potential suppliers for catering services may be limited: providers need production facilities, storage space, specialized vehicles, and staff; they must comply with sanitary requirements and deliver prepared meals to a frontline region. One plausible explanation is that a single specialized catering operator operates in this segment of frontline communities, while other suppliers are unwilling or unable to handle the complex logistics.
Another fact is particularly noteworthy: Service Rest Group LLC had already participated in two of the canceled procurements, UA-2026-08-05-007043-a and UA-2026-08-07-011663-a.
Procurement UA-2026-08-05-007043-a was canceled specifically because Service Rest Group LLC stated a final bid price of UAH 540,150.00, excluding VAT. However, Appendix No. 4 to the tender documentation, titled “Tender Proposal,” submitted by the company listed a total bid price of UAH 662,970.00 excluding VAT, which did not match the price entered by the bidder in the electronic procurement system.
The discrepancy was not corrected within 24 hours of the notice being posted, and the tender was canceled. Nine days later, the contracting authority announced a repeat procurement with an estimated value of UAH 664,800. Service Rest Group LLC won and signed a contract with the Orlivka Educational Complex for UAH 662,970.00, excluding VAT—the same amount stated in its original tender proposal.
This sequence of events does not, in itself, prove coordinated action. However, it raises questions about the calculations used to set the estimated value of the repeat procurement at almost exactly the price the supplier had already quoted in the previous procedure.
Procurement UA-2026-08-07-011663-a was canceled because the estimated value had been entered incorrectly when the procurement was published.
What is known about the winning company
Service Rest Group LLC was registered in Kryvii Rih in January 2018. Its owner, director, and ultimate beneficial owner is Tetiana Briushkova. The company specializes in supplying prepared meals and providing catering services.
According to Opendatabot, the company had participated in 15 tenders since 2022. The sales volume recorded by the platform, specifically through tender procurements, amounted to UAH 533,660 in 2025 and UAH 2,355,461 in the first nine months of 2026.
In 2025, the company’s total revenue was approximately UAH 116.99 million, with a net profit of UAH 5.83 million. During the first two quarters of 2026, its total revenue was UAH 69.1 million, with a net profit of UAH 3.8 million.
Although the company has very little registered share capital, the actual scale of its business is considerably larger. Its revenue is generated not only through public procurement, suggesting the company is not dependent on public contracts.
The company employed 141 people in 2025 and 181 in 2026. This is another indicator that it conducts substantial business operations rather than merely participating formally in tenders.
According to publicly available registries, Service Rest Group LLC does not own its own production facilities. Its production and storage premises and technological equipment are leased, as confirmed by the tender documentation the company submitted. Leasing facilities is not, in itself, a violation and does not indicate that a supplier is incapable of fulfilling a contract.
However, these procurements raise a specific operational risk: prepared meals must be produced in Kryvii Rih and delivered to the contracting authorities’ facilities in the Kherson region. This requires reliable temperature control and sanitary conditions, logistics, and timely deliveries under difficult security conditions. The question is whether the available resources are sufficient in capacity and can ensure uninterrupted meal production and delivery.
In a comment to the Center for Investigative Journalism, Hanna Perezva, director of the Bilokrynytsia Main Gymnasium, assured the publication that meals are delivered hot from Kryvyi Rih within two hours and meet all quality standards.
According to YouControl, court records contain documents mentioning Service Rest Group LLC, including both administrative and criminal proceedings. In particular, in 2025, the company appeared in several procedural documents relating to criminal investigation No. 12024100120000163, dated July 23, 2024 (cases No. 758/1894/25, No. 758/1874/25, No. 758/1871/25, No. 758/3436/25, and No. 758/3834/25), concerning the alleged misappropriation of public funds in public procurement. In February 2025, the Podilskyi District Court of Kyiv froze funds in Service Rest Group LLC’s bank accounts as part of this investigation. The court ruling dated March 13, 2025, states that, according to the investigators’ theory, Service Rest Group LLC and several other companies may have been used to reduce tax liabilities, create documentary cover for transactions in which no goods were actually supplied, and convert non-cash funds into cash. In March 2025, the court lifted the freezes on the funds of Service Rest Group LLC and the other companies, stating that the needs of the pretrial investigation at that time did not justify continued interference with the owners' property rights.
SASU places the procurements under scrutiny
On September 29, 2026, SASU launched a monitoring review of procurement UA-2026-08-14-005994-a, conducted by the Orlivka Main Educational Complex of the Kochubeivka Village Council. The review was initiated based on automated risk indicators, and the contracting authority was asked a series of questions regarding the justification of the estimated value, the tender documentation, the winner’s material and technical resources, and the winner’s supporting documents.
The monitoring, therefore, covers the entire key procurement cycle, from determining the estimated value to selecting the winning bidder.
During the review, SASU noted that the tender documentation did not fully specify how information about the ultimate beneficial owners of a non-resident bidder was to be confirmed. However, SASU has not yet issued its final findings. It is therefore premature to speak of definitively established violations or a need to terminate the contract at this stage. The monitoring is expected to be completed by October 21, 2026, after which the state financial control authority’s final position will be known.
A similar situation applies to procurement UA-2026-08-20-013258-a, announced by the Bilokrynytsia Main Gymnasium. SASU also launched a monitoring review based on automated risk indicators. The issues under review include the justification of the estimated value, the compliance of the tender documentation with legislation, vehicle-related documents, and documents submitted by the winner. The review is still ongoing.
Important: The fact that a procurement is being monitored does not mean that a violation has been established.
Conclusions
The case involving four catering procurements in the Kherson region is about more than one company winning four contracts. What matters more is the combination of circumstances: four different contracting authorities, a lack of genuine price competition, repeat procedures, substantial increases in estimated values in three cases, and the near-exact match between the price in the repeat procurement and the supplier’s earlier bid in the Orlivka Educational Complex tender.
At the same time, objective factors may help explain the situation, including the specific requirements of catering services, complex logistics, operations in a frontline region, the need for specialized infrastructure, and a limited number of potential suppliers.
The key question, therefore, is not why the same company won all four procurements, but whether the price of each procurement can be justified with supporting documentation and whether genuine alternatives to this supplier existed in the relevant market.
Answers to these questions will help distinguish the objective realities of the catering market in the frontline areas of the Kherson region from circumstances that may warrant further scrutiny.
This material was prepared with the financial support of the European Union and Equal Rights & Independent Media (ERIM). Its contents are the sole responsibility of Kherson Regional Charitable Foundation "Union" and do not necessarily reflect the views of the EU and ERIM.
.png)